
Catherine is always first into the boardroom. When the CEO arrives ten minutes early, she’s already there, surrounded by paper, the agenda printed out, laptop open, so absorbed in her reading that she jumps when he speaks.
An hour later, after everyone else has had their say, the room waits for Catherine. And waits. Eventually she gathers her papers into a neat stack, places the top sheet carefully to her right, the second sheet carefully to her left, looks up and says she’d like to make the following observations.
What follows is a series of questions. If staff go offsite, who answers the phones? Will we have to pay overtime? What will it all cost? Then a plan: a detailed staff survey, a period of analysis, a working paper with recommendations, and then a decision. Dennis‘s face has turned scarlet.
That’s Catherine, who heads up Service Delivery at West IT in my book Why Do People Act Like That? She is the classic Conscientious, the High C, or Blue.
Who is the High C?
In DISC terms, the Conscientious style is slow paced and task focussed. They make up about 27% of Australians.
The High C is the ultimate details person. They’re accurate, cautious, logical, systematic and thorough. They’re often quite introverted, and while they may not say much, they are watching everything closely and calculating what happens next.
Others sometimes see them as pessimists. They’re not. They’re realists with the facts at their fingertips. Cutting corners is never an option. There is no instruction manual too long and no fine print too small. Hand a High I a twenty-page legal document and they’ll wither. Hand it to a High C and they’ll come back refreshed, having found three things nobody else noticed.
Which brings me to a warning. Never try to outsmart a High C. In the book, Charlene sits quietly at a bar while a group debates whether electric cars could ever work in Singapore. When there’s a gap, she calmly lists the price, the range, the acceleration figures and the number of charging stations from each provider on the island. The room goes silent. Charlene sips her drink.
One more thing. A High C doesn’t need applause. Make a fuss of one in front of the whole company and you’ll likely hear, “Thank you, but really, I was just doing my job.”
How to get a yes from a High C
This story from the book shows the Platinum Rule better than anything I could explain.
Heather, a training manager, couldn’t get her boss Jim to approve anything. Her method was to grab fifteen minutes in his diary, rush in, sketch her idea on the whiteboard, talk fast, wave her arms about and finish with “So, what do you think?” Jim, sitting quietly taking notes, would look over his glasses and say one of three things: “I’ll think about it.” “I’ll look into it.” “I’ll take that on board.”
Heather was an Influencer speaking to a Conscientious in the wrong language. So she changed her approach:
- She booked a meeting at least three days out.
- She emailed the full proposal beforehand under a plain, information-based subject line: the process, the costings, what’s in it for the organisation, what’s in it for Jim, and her recommendations.
- At the meeting she brought two printed copies and slid one across the desk.
- She walked through it step by step, slowly, voice low, hands tucked under her legs so she couldn’t gesture.
- She asked if he had questions, then sat and waited through the silence, with answers to his likely objections already prepared.
Three days later she rang to say it had worked. She was so excited she barely needed the phone. You could have heard her from across town.
How to spot a High C
- A brief, arm’s-length handshake, sometimes just the fingertips. Post Covid, expect a small bow or a nod from a safe distance.
- Conservative clothes, often from a few seasons back. Why buy new when the old ones still fit?
- A spotless desk. Everything in its place and a place for everything. As Catherine puts it, a cluttered desk leads to a cluttered mind.
- A slow, even, low voice with little change in pitch.
- Formal phone manners. Full name, straight to business. And it’s Catherine, thanks, never Cathy.
- Emails packed with data or several attachments, which they assume you have read in full.
- Why questions. “Why does it work this way?” and “Why is this step needed?” Plus a favourite line in meetings: “Just one more question.”
What stresses a High C
- Mistakes, especially repeated ones. They become picky and make sure everyone knows the error wasn’t theirs.
- Spontaneous change. Worse still is “This could be risky, but let’s do it anyway.”
- Being dropped into something with no time to prepare.
- “That didn’t work, let’s just get creative and see what happens.”
Under stress a High C can turn pessimistic, withdraw from the conversation, or dig in and act as if the change never happened. Some freeze altogether, because doing nothing feels safer than doing the wrong thing. Others get sharp and sarcastic, so be ready for that too.
The remedy is space and time. Let them think it through and find their own way to a better outcome. If that doesn’t work, roll up your sleeves and work through it alongside them.
How to work with a High C
- Be consistent. Predictability builds their trust.
- Be polite, yet formal. Skip the small talk and get to the substance.
- Put it in writing first. Give them time to read before you ask them to decide.
- Stick to the facts. Emotional arguments won’t move them.
- Ask for their detailed input. In meetings, stop and ask what they think. They won’t always volunteer it, and sometimes they bring the gold.
- Praise in private. Quiet, specific recognition means far more than a public fuss.
The upside
The book describes a team activity where groups race to assemble a Lego helicopter with no instructions, only a finished model at the front of the room. One day a team of High C engineers asked several clarifying questions, then spent around twenty minutes planning without touching a single piece. The D and I teams were already submitting wrong answers. When the engineers finally started, they built it in a minute and a half, a record nobody has come close to since.
That’s the High C. They may be slow to start, but they rarely have to start twice. If a High C recommends something important, you can rest assured it’s probably the best option. They’ve done the homework.
The one thing to remember: You can’t rush a High C into a decision. Give them the facts and the time, and they’ll give you their best.
Not sure who on your team, or your client’s team, is a High C? Explore DISC assessments or talk to Lindsay about where DISC fits in your work.